Large Customer Grid Upgrade Cost Rule

Summary#

The Ratepayer Protection Act would amend the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 (PURPA), an existing federal law. Its goal is to have large-load customers cover the full incremental cost of electric-system upgrades needed to serve them; the bill does not itself require every state to adopt that standard.

  • If a state or nonregulated electric utility adopts the standard, rates for a covered customer must be designed to recover the full incremental cost of necessary generation, transmission, and distribution upgrades from that customer. This applies even if the customer ends its contract or stops buying electricity.
  • Before making a necessary upgrade, an electric utility must require the customer to provide financial assurances or contributions to cover the upgrade’s cost.
  • A covered large-load customer is a non-residential consumer seeking or entering an electricity-sale agreement, on or after enactment, for facilities with a combined peak demand of at least 100 megawatts at one site or campus.
  • State regulators and nonregulated utilities generally must start considering the standard within one year and complete consideration and make a determination within two years. The bill does not require them to adopt it.
  • Those deadlines do not apply to a utility if, before enactment, the state had implemented the standard or a comparable one, held a proceeding to consider it, or the state legislature had voted on its implementation.

What it means for you#

  • Large-load customers: Where the standard is adopted, you would be responsible for the full incremental cost of upgrades needed to serve your load. You would also have to provide financial assurances or contributions before the utility makes an upgrade.
  • Other electricity customers: The standard is intended to reduce the chance that other customers pay costs assigned to a large-load customer. The bill does not guarantee that every state or utility will adopt the standard.
  • Utilities and state regulators: They would have to consider the standard on the bill’s schedule unless a prior state action qualifies for the exception. If adopted, utilities would have duties concerning rates and financial assurances.
  • General public: The bill does not directly change household eligibility for electricity service, set household rates, or create a new utility or customer program. This is an introduced bill, not an enacted law.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s estimated fiscal impact.

  • The bill requires utilities to seek financial assurances or contributions before making covered upgrades, but does not specify the form or amount.
  • The bill provides no estimate of state, utility, customer, or administrative costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “full, incremental cost,” “necessary” upgrades, or a “comparable” state standard.
  • It does not set a method for calculating costs, handling cost changes, or resolving disputes over who caused or benefits from an upgrade.
  • It does not say what financial assurances or contributions may be required, or what happens if they exceed or fall short of the eventual cost.
  • The bill does not explain how state proceedings must work or how regulators should decide whether to adopt the standard.
  • The parent Act was not supplied, so the existing PURPA rules and state practices could not be checked against the bill’s amendments.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that customers creating a need for major upgrades should bear those costs rather than leave them to other electricity customers.
  • Requiring assurances or contributions before construction could help protect utilities and customers if a large customer later ends its contract or stops buying power.
  • The state consideration process leaves regulators room to decide whether the standard fits their circumstances.

Case against#

  • The bill requires consideration, not adoption. A state could decide not to adopt the standard, so the bill may not ensure that large-load customers pay these costs everywhere.
  • The terms for calculating costs are undefined, which could lead to disputes or different approaches across states.
  • Upfront assurances or contributions could be a significant burden for customers seeking large upgrades; the bill gives no method for setting or reviewing them.
  • The bill does not spell out how costs should be allocated when an upgrade also serves other customers.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 254

    Defeated100 members voted

    Cloture on the motion to proceed to the measure not invoked in Senate by Yea-Nay Vote. 57 - 43.

    AGAINST · 43FOR · 57

    43Against

    • Democratic41
    • Independent2

    57For

    • Republican53
    • Democratic4
  2. Division No. 312

    Passed420 members voted

    On Motion to Suspend the Rules and Pass, as Amended: H.R. 9340

    FOR · 417AGAINST · 3

    417For

    • Republican210
    • Democratic206
    • Independent1

    3Against

    • Democratic3