Truman Scholarship Clean House

Full Title:
Truman Scholarship Clean House Act

Summary#

This bill makes many changes to the Harry S. Truman Scholarship program.

Key changes include a new definition of what it means to be "affiliated with" a political party. The Foundation's Board of Trustees would be restructured to 13 members: one appointee each from the House Speaker, House minority leader, Senate majority leader, and Senate minority leader; eight presidential appointees (with advice and consent of the Senate) limited so no more than four of those eight may be affiliated with the same political party at appointment; and the Secretary of Education (or their designee) serving ex officio but ineligible to be Chair. The bill requires the existing board to be dissolved 90 days after enactment and new members appointed under the new rules. Board terms, term limits, and a seven-member quorum rule are added.

The bill creates Regional Review Panels to select scholars. Panels must have at least five members appointed annually by a two-thirds Board vote, and no more than half the panel members may be affiliated with the same political party. It sets specific selection criteria: community service and government involvement, leadership, academic performance (including writing and analytical skills), and the suitability of the proposed graduate program for a public service career. The bill adds or clarifies eligibility rules (including students from Puerto Rico and certain islands, and citizenship or permanent residency requirements) and lists disqualifying factors such as leading a student organization at the time it was suspended or expelled, suspension or expulsion from a college for disciplinary reasons, or a felony conviction. It also says the Foundation may not disfavor applicants because they plan to pursue certain graduate degrees (for example, MBA or MD).

The bill adds conditions under which scholarship payments may be stopped: failing to submit required reports or providing false/misleading information, failing to begin use of the scholarship within four years (unless extended), serving in leadership of a student organization at the time of an incident that led to that organization's suspension or expulsion, suspension or expulsion from school for disciplinary reasons, or a felony conviction. Before stopping payments, the Foundation must give reasonable notice stating the reason and provide an opportunity for a hearing. If payments are stopped or if a recipient fails to be employed in public service for three of the first seven years after finishing the graduate degree, the recipient must repay the total amount received plus 6 percent annual interest. The bill requires recipients be notified of these conditions before the first payment.

The Executive Secretary must be appointed by a two-thirds vote of the Board, serve a 4-year term, and may be reappointed up to two times. The current Executive Secretary may continue only until a new one is appointed or until 90 days after a quorum of the new Board is appointed. The bill also requires the Foundation to post and preserve certain materials (press releases, program announcements, and biographies of scholarship recipients) on a public website in unaltered format, with any edits clearly identified and the original kept available. These posting rules apply to past and future materials.

The bill applies only to scholarships awarded on or after the date of enactment. It also says previously awarded scholarships are not invalidated or revoked and that the Foundation should continue to fund and administer them.

What it means for you#

  • Students: There are clearer eligibility and selection rules. New disqualifications and repayment rules are added. You could lose scholarship payments for failing to follow reporting rules, for certain disciplinary findings, or for felony convictions. Repayment would include the full amount received plus 6% interest if payments are stopped or if you do not work in public service for 3 of the first 7 years after your graduate degree. You must be notified of these conditions before your first payment.
  • Applicants from Puerto Rico and certain islands are explicitly covered by eligibility language in the bill.
  • Selection panels: Regional Review Panels will be appointed annually, must meet size and political-balance limits, and must use the listed selection criteria.
  • Foundation leadership: The Board will be reconstituted under new appointment rules, existing trustees will be removed 90 days after enactment, and the Executive Secretary will serve fixed 4-year terms with reappointment limits.
  • Public: Certain Foundation publications must be kept publicly available and preserved in unaltered form, with edits tracked.

Expenses#

No publicly available information on budget estimates, new appropriations, or cost detail is included in the bill text provided.

Proponents' View#

No publicly available information in the bill text about supporters' stated reasons or arguments for the changes.

Opponents' View#

No publicly available information in the bill text about opponents' stated reasons or objections to the changes.