Child Care Fees Would Face Six-Month Refund Rule

Summary#

SB 1234 would amend 1973 PA 116, the law on licensing and regulating child care organizations, by adding a rule about certain fees paid by prospective families. Its stated purpose is to regulate fees charged by child care organizations; the bill does not guarantee a child care spot. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • A child care organization would generally have to refund application, deposit, or wait-list fees if the child is not enrolled within six months after payment. It may keep a reasonable administrative fee.
  • The Department of Lifelong Education, Advancement, and Potential must consult families who use child care and licensed providers, then set the amount of administrative fees that may be kept within 90 days after the bill takes effect.
  • The refund rule would not apply in three listed situations: the family refuses an offered spot; the family enrolls and signs a contract saying the fee is nonrefundable; or a fee was paid to hold a spot and that spot is offered.
  • Families must make a written request for a refund. After receiving it, the organization must refund eligible fees and may remove the family from the wait list.
  • Organizations must provide fee schedules and refund processes to prospective families at specified points, and give enrolled families updates within 30 days of a change.
  • Violations would be subject to a civil fine of up to $100 after the first violation, with exceptions for good-faith administrative errors and certain corrective action after a first violation.

What it means for you#

  • Families seeking child care: If a child is not enrolled within six months, you would generally be entitled to a refund of the listed fees, minus any allowed administrative fee. You would have to request it in writing. The listed exceptions could mean no refund is due.
  • Families on wait lists or with enrolled children: You would be entitled to receive the fee schedule and refund process at the times specified in the bill. If the organization changes them, it must send updated information to enrolled families within 30 days.
  • Child care organizations: You would have to follow the refund and information rules. You may keep only the administrative amount set by the department, and may remove a family from a wait list after refunding.
  • Department: It must consult the named groups and set the allowable administrative fee amount. The bill does not create a new agency.
  • Current-law comparison: The existing law text was not supplied, so what protections already exist and what this would newly change cannot be verified.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • Child care organizations may have to return fees, while being allowed to retain the administrative amount set by the department.
  • The bill permits civil fines of up to $100 after the first violation; it gives no estimate of fine revenue or enforcement costs.
  • The department must do the fee-setting work, but the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not state a start date in the supplied text; its deadlines depend on when it takes effect.
  • It does not say how the fine is imposed or who enforces the section. The wording about fines after a first violation and corrective action is not fully clear.
  • It does not set a deadline for paying a refund after the organization receives a written request.
  • It does not explain how the department will decide what amount is a reasonable administrative fee.
  • It is unclear how the refund rule interacts with existing child care rules or contracts. The current law was not supplied for comparison.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to protect families from losing certain fees when a child is not enrolled within six months.
  • Requiring organizations to provide fee schedules and refund information could help families understand the costs and terms before or during enrollment.
  • Having the department set the allowable administrative fee amount could limit what organizations keep from an otherwise refundable fee.

Case against#

  • The listed exceptions could leave families without a refund even when enrollment does not occur, including when a spot is offered but refused.
  • The bill does not explain how families can challenge a denied refund or how quickly refunds must be paid.
  • The maximum fine is limited to $100 after the first violation, and the enforcement process is not specified.
  • The department must set an administrative fee amount, but the bill does not explain how that amount will be determined.