Water Board chair pay approved

Summary#

On May 12, 2026, Calgary City Council approved compensation for the Water Utility Oversight Board (WUOB) and passed Bylaw 17M2026 at third reading, establishing a committee to help recruit the Board Chair. The stated goal is to support recruitment for the WUOB, which Council had established earlier.

  • The Board Chair will receive an annual retainer of $70,000; each Board Member will receive $30,000. Each is also eligible for a $1,000 fee per meeting once the Board holds more than eight meetings in a year.
  • The Chair’s recruitment is exempt from the City Clerk’s Office recruitment and advertising process. The report says an external recruitment firm will be used.
  • Council appointed Councillor Ward and Councillor Pantazopoulos to the Selection Committee, with Councillor Ward as Chair, and appointed Siegfried Kiefer as its public member. Their terms end when Council appoints the WUOB Chair.

What it means for you#

  • Water customers and taxpayers: The decision does not itself change water rates or water service. City staff say WUOB costs will be factored into future water rates.
  • WUOB members: The approved retainers and meeting fees set their compensation.
  • City staff and the Selection Committee: The committee is to support recruitment of the Board Chair. The public member’s appointment is to be announced after the appointee is notified and accepts.

Money#

The report says the decision’s costs can be covered by the $600,000 preliminary WUOB budget Council approved on March 17, 2026; it gives no cost breakdown.

  • City staff expect further costs for day-to-day operations, including administrative support. They say these costs will be brought forward in recommendations for the 2027 budget.
  • City staff say WUOB costs, including compensation, will be factored into future water rates. The report gives no rate impact or total cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The full text of Bylaw 17M2026 and the attachments are not included, so the committee’s full powers, procedures and membership rules cannot be verified. The report describes a proposed committee including the Mayor and two voting Councillors, but Council’s recorded appointment motion names two Councillors.
  • The decision does not state when the committee will finish its work or when the bylaw takes effect.
  • The report anticipates a Council decision on the Board Chair in July 2026 and Board Member appointments in October, but those are expected dates, not guarantees.
  • The report does not break down how much of the approved $600,000 budget will go to compensation, recruitment or support.

Case for#

  • City staff say the WUOB will oversee a water utility that provides an essential public service and makes up a significant part of the City’s finances. They say specialist compensation and a tailored recruitment process are needed for its work.
  • City staff say the board is expected to face a high workload during its first two years. The approved compensation uses the top of the ranges recommended by an external recruitment firm.
  • City staff say independent oversight could give Council clearer insight into water system risks, investments and performance.

Case against#

  • City staff say the WUOB’s costs are materially higher than those of other City boards, committees and commissions, and will be factored into future water rates. The report gives no estimate of the rate impact.
  • The Advisory Group said the recommended pay may be too low to attract the needed expertise or fairly reflect the work, and suggested reconsidering compensation after the initial three-year term.
  • Councillors Dhaliwal, Atkinson, Chabot and Wyness voted against the bylaw and compensation motion. The minutes do not give their reasons.

Votes

Public Hearing Meeting of Council, item 9.1 (Water Utility Oversight Board – Compensation and Selection, EC2026-0383): That with respect to Report EC2026-0383, the following be adopted, after amendment: That Council: - Approve the annual retainers of $70,000 for the Board Chair and $30,000 for Board Members and approve a meeting fee of $1,000 per meeting when the number of meetings exceeds eight per year. - Pursuant to section 5.12.1 of the Council Policy on the Governance and Appointment of Boards, Commissions an…

For (73%)
Against (27%)

Public Hearing Meeting of Council, item 9.1 (Water Utility Oversight Board – Compensation and Selection, EC2026-0383): That Bylaw 17M2026 be introduced and read a first time.

For (73%)
Against (27%)

Public Hearing Meeting of Council, item 9.1 (Water Utility Oversight Board – Compensation and Selection, EC2026-0383): That Bylaw 17M2026 be read a second time.

For (73%)
Against (27%)

Public Hearing Meeting of Council, item 9.1 (Water Utility Oversight Board – Compensation and Selection, EC2026-0383): That Bylaw 17M2026 be read a third time.

For (73%)
Against (27%)

Public Hearing Meeting of Council, item 9.1 (Water Utility Oversight Board – Compensation and Selection, EC2026-0383): That with respect to Report EC2026-0383, the following be adopted, after amendment: That Council: - Appoint Councillor Ward and Councillor Pantazopoulos as Members of the Water Utility Oversight Board Chair Selection Committee, and Councillor Ward as Chair, for terms to expire upon the appointment by Council of a Chair of the Water Utility Oversight Board; - Notwithstanding Part C of the Council P…

For (93%)
Against (7%)

Executive Committee, item 7.6 (Water Utility Oversight Board – Compensation and Selection, EC2026-0383): That with respect to Report EC2026-0383, the following be approved, after amendment: That Executive Committee: - Forward this Report and Attachments to the 2026 May 12 Public Hearing Meeting of Council. That Executive Committee recommends that Council: - Approve the annual retainers of $70,000 for the Board Chair and $30,000 for Board Members and approve a meeting fee of $1,000 per meeting when th…

For (70%)
Against (30%)